# Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo dupe: Gotham Dust

The cheapest Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo dupe we list is under $50: Oakcha Gotham Dust Extrait de Parfum, $29.95 for 50 ml at Oakcha's list price ($0.60 per ml). 1 fragrance is described by its brand as inspired by Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo. List price on Oct 13.

The original: Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo, no price yet. Page: https://eauindex.com/fragrance/carolina-herrera/212-vip-black-ny-rodeo.md

## Dupes (each brand's own claim, quoted with its source)

1. Oakcha Gotham Dust Extrait de Parfum: $29.95 for 50 ml ($0.60/ml), list price at Oakcha on Oct 13.
   Oakcha says: "Inspired by: Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo" (source: https://www.oakcha.com/products/gotham-dust)
   Page: https://eauindex.com/fragrance/oakcha/gotham-dust-extrait-de-parfum.md

List price on Oct 13.

## How we judged this dupe (reviewed Oct 4, 2026)

The match is Oakcha's own claim, quoted with a link to its source; claims last checked on the house's site Oct 4, 2026. Notes not compared: Carolina Herrera lists no notes for 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo. Price per ml is the lowest price we could check divided by the bottle size: a live store price when there is one, else the house's list price.

Dupes listed here are the dupe brands' own statements about what inspired them, quoted with a link to the source. EauIndex does not claim any two fragrances smell the same. Neither EauIndex nor these brands are affiliated with the original fragrance house. Brand names are used only to identify products.

## Questions

### What is the best Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo dupe under $50?

EauIndex does not rate how dupes smell, so this is by price: the cheapest Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo dupe under $50 is Oakcha Gotham Dust Extrait de Parfum, $29.95 for 50 ml at Oakcha's list price ($0.60 per ml). 1 of the 1 dupes we list has a bottle under $50. Each is its brand's own claim, quoted and linked on this page. List price on Oct 13.

### How much cheaper is a Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo dupe?

We have no current US price for the original Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo, so we cannot put a number on the saving. The cheapest dupe we list is Oakcha Gotham Dust Extrait de Parfum, $29.95 for 50 ml at Oakcha's list price ($0.60 per ml). List price on Oct 13.

### What is the most affordable Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo dupe?

By bottle price, Oakcha Gotham Dust Extrait de Parfum: $29.95 for 50 ml at Oakcha's list price ($0.60 per ml). It is also the lowest price per ml we list. Each is its brand's own claim, quoted and linked on this page. List price on Oct 13.

### Is Oakcha Gotham Dust a dupe of Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo?

Oakcha describes Gotham Dust as inspired by Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo, in its own words: "Inspired by: Carolina Herrera 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo". Gotham Dust is $29.95 for 50 ml at Oakcha's list price ($0.60/ml). List price on Oct 13. EauIndex lists brand-declared dupes only and does not claim they smell the same.

### What are the dupes for 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo?

Oakcha describes Gotham Dust as inspired by 212 VIP Black NY Rodeo ($0.60 per ml). These are the dupe brands' own statements; EauIndex and those brands are not affiliated with Carolina Herrera.

Canonical page: https://eauindex.com/dupes/carolina-herrera/212-vip-black-ny-rodeo